Comparison between the Marshall and Robbins definition of economics...

 Marshall defined economics as a science of material welfare. It emphasized on human welfare through the attainment and use of the material requisites of well-being. On the other hand, Robbins's definition of economics as a science of scarcity and choice emphasized on maximum satisfaction while satisfying unlimited wants through limited means which have alternative uses. From intensive analysis of these two definitions, we find the following similarities and dis-similarities:-

Similarities..... 

1. Study of human efforts: Both Marshall and Robbins considered economics as the study of human behavior or efforts for the material welfare of human beings or maximum satisfaction of human beings. 

2. Study of rational man: Both definitions are based on the assumption of rational man. The function of attaining and using material things for welfare of human beings in Marshall's definition and maximizing satisfaction through the scarce resources in Robbins's definition can be achieved only by rational man. 

3. Wealth and scarce means: Marshall used the term wealth as the means to attain material welfare of human beings, while Robbins used the term scarce means to attain maximum satisfaction. In fact, the term scarce means is broad than wealth but the meaning and sense of these two terms is same.  

4.Welfare and maximum satisfaction: In Marshall definition, man should use the wealth for the for the material welfare of human beings and in Robbins's definition, man should use the scarce means for the maximum satisfaction of human beings. But the meaning and sense of these two terms is almost similar. 

Dis-similarities.... 

1. Definition: Marshall defined economics as a science of material welfare whereas Robbins defined economics as a science of scarcity and choice. 

2. Classifictory and analytical: Marshall's definition is considered as classifictory definition because it classified human activities into different parts i.e social- non social,material- non material, etc.whereas Robbins's definition considered as analytical definition because it studies the behavior of mankind in relation to unlimited wants and limited means which have alternative uses. 

3. Social and human science: According to Marshall, economics is a social science and therefore it studies the activities of ordinary man who lives in the society. Whereas Robbins defined economics as a human science and it studies human behavior whether they live in the society and out of the society. 

4. Normative and positive science: According to Marshall, economics is a normative science and explains the facts not as they are but as they ought to be. Whereas, according to Robbins, economics is a positive science and explains the facts as they are but not as they ought to be. 

5. Practical and theoretical: It's assumed that Marshall's definition of economics is simple, easy to understand and practical. So his definition has human touch whereas the Robbins's definition of economics is theoretical and has different characters and it isn't able to touch human feelings. 

6. Applicability of different economies: Marshall's definition is applicable only in monetary capitalist economy whereas Robbins's definition is applicable in all types of economies whether it's capitalist or socialist. 

Comments

Post a Comment

If you have any problem then share with me.

Popular posts from this blog

Adam Smith Definition of Economics

 Adam Smith's definition of Economics...  Adam Smith, founder of modern economics and the leader of classical economists developed economics as a separate social science. So he is regarded as a father of Modern Economics. He wrote a book on the subject named " An Enquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of the Nations " which was published in 1776AD. This book is regarded as the holy book of economics and popularly know as'The Wealth of Nations'. The name of the book is itself sufficient to understand what economics is and the subject matter does it cover.                    According to him, economics is the study of the nature and causes of the wealth of the nation and it is concerned with production and increase of nation's wealth. The term wealth means sufficient money resources. This definition was supported by various classical economists like J. B. Say, J. S. Mill, F. A Walker, David Ricardo, Thomas Robert Mathus etc. According to J. B Say, &quo
Read more

What is demand and its various types?

Image
 Definition of Demand... In common language, demand is same as desire. But in economics, demand means effective desire which is supported by ability to pay and willingness to pay for goods and services. For example: if a poor person wanted to have an iPhone, it’s just his/her desire because he/she doesn’t have ability to pay for iPhone. Similarly, if a rich person wanted to buy an iPhone , it may be a demand because he/she has ability to pay for iPhone. To have a complete definition of demand, the price per unit of a commodity and the period of time in which quantity is being demanded should be clearly stated. Therefore, demand means desire, ability to pay and willingness to pay for goods and services at certain price during a certain period of time. According to Benham, “The demand for anything at a given price is the amount of it, which will be bought per unit for time at that price”. Thus demand for a commodity is defined as a schedule which shows various amounts of that commodi
Read more

Difference between movement along the demand curve and Shift in demand curve

Image
  Difference between movement along the demand curve and Shift in demand curve....  The main difference between movement along the demand curve and Shift in demand curve are as given below: 1. When the commodity experience change in both the quantity demanded and price, causing the curve to move in specific direction, is known as movement along the demand curve. But when the price of a commodity remains constant but there is a change in quantity demanded due to some other factors, causing the curve to shift in a particular side, it is called Shift in demand curve.  2. Movement in demand curve occurs along the curve, whereas the shift in demand curve changes its position due to change in original demand relationship.  3. Price is the main determinant of movement along the demand curve whereas other factors except price are the determinant of shift in demand curve.  4. Movement along the demand curve indicates the change in quantity demanded whereas Shift in demand curve indicates the ch
Read more